Quote checker
Compare roofing quotes with a sharper eye for scope and warranty.
Roofing proposals can look similar until you break out the product line, tear-off, flashing, and cleanup details.
Last updated: June 9, 2026 · Reviewed by the MyQuoteCheck Editorial Team
What this checker highlights
- Shingle brand not specified
- Underlayment unclear
- Disposal not listed
- Flashing details missing
- Warranty unclear
What a complete roofing quote should make clear
Every trade has different details that matter most. This checker helps you look for the ones that should not be left implied.
- Shingle brand and product line
- Underlayment type
- Flashing
- Tear-off/disposal
- Ventilation
- Workmanship warranty
Red flags
Common signs a quote needs clarification
The table below turns the most common warnings into a clearer follow-up question.
| Red flag | Why it matters | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Shingle brand not specified | The roof system components may not be fully named. | What shingle brand and product line are included? |
| Underlayment unclear | A tear-off versus overlay decision affects scope and price. | Is old roof removal included? |
| Disposal not listed | Underlayment and ice/water protection may be missing. | What flashing work is included? |
| Flashing details missing | Flashing details can be left too vague for a fair comparison. | What workmanship warranty applies? |
| Warranty unclear | Warranty language may not tell you what is actually covered. | What shingle brand and product line are included? |
Questions to ask before approving
Turn the gaps into written follow-up questions
If the quote does not clearly address these points, ask the provider to confirm them in writing before you approve the job.
What shingle brand and product line are included?
Is old roof removal included?
What flashing work is included?
What workmanship warranty applies?
Related reading
Helpful articles and next steps
Use these resources to compare what you see in the quote and get a clearer view of the scope.
Resource article
What should be included in a roofing quote?
Learn which roofing quote details matter most, including shingle brand, underlayment, flashing, disposal, and warranty terms.
Resource article
Should you choose the cheapest contractor quote?
A practical guide to comparing low bids against scope, exclusions, materials, warranty terms, and change-order risk.
Resource article
How to compare two service quotes
Use a simple side-by-side process to compare service quotes for scope, exclusions, materials, and risk.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
These answers are meant to help you decide whether the quote is clear enough to compare.
What should I confirm first?
Start with the quote items that most affect scope and price, such as shingle brand and product line.
What if the quote is short but seems reasonable?
A short quote can still be fine, but it is worth checking whether the important details are written down clearly enough for you to compare it with other bids.
What shingle brand and product line are included?
Use this as a follow-up question so the provider can confirm the missing detail in writing.
Is old roof removal included?
Use this as a follow-up question so the provider can confirm the missing detail in writing.
Should I get a second quote?
If the scope is unclear, the total is high, or the quote leaves out important terms, comparing it with another provider can make the decision easier.
Disclaimer
This page is educational and based only on the information provided. It is not a substitute for advice from a licensed professional.